Academicus International Scientific Journal

Title:
Effectiveness and legitimacy of Amicus Curiae submission before WTO judiciary organs.  

Author(s):
Dr. (PhD) Rezana Konomi
rezikonomi@yahoo.com
Faculty of Law, Tirana University, Albania
0009-0009-3214-4424
Dr. (PhD) Dorina Gjipali
dorinagjipali@uamd.edu.al
Faculty of Political and Legal Studies, Aleksandër Moisiu University, Durrës, Albania
0009-0007-7058-3183
MSc. Ntastin Perola
perolantastin@gmail.com
Erasmus University Rotterdam, Netherlands
0009-0002-9473-8120

Abstract:

‘Amicus curiae’ is a latin term that means a ‘friend of the court’. In essence, this term encapsulates “[a] person who is not a party to a lawsuit but who petitions the court or is requested by the court to file a brief in the action because that person has a strong interest in the subject matter’’. This presents a non-party with the opportunity to submit its views regarding the outcome of a particular dispute regarding a broad range of issues (e.g. the appraisal of the merits in light of contemporary developments, the submission of factual elements etc.). These submissions have been present also during the predecessor of the current institutionalized WTO, namely the GATT system, albeit never being considered by those panels. However, there was gradual a shift in the panels’ position regarding the engagement with amicus curiae submissions. In this regard, the first amicus curiae submission in the US - Gasoline case was rejected by the WTO panel of that case. It was only the US - Shrimp case that paved the way for amicus curiae to find their way into the WTO adjudicative system. This was followed by a great polarization regarding the legitimacy of engaging with submission of non-state actors in an inherently inter-governmental system. This paper, therefore, sustains that the amicus curiae submissions facilitate effectiveness if exercised within the constraints of legitimacy (as conceptualized within the ambit of the WTO), by framing the analysis through doctrinal discussions as well as empirical evidence that is derived from other research that is appropriately referenced.


Keywords:
amicus curiae; GATT system; WTO judiciary organs;

Full Text PDF:

Cite:   

References:
View complete reference list, click here

Digital Object Identifier DOI:


Licensing:   Creative Commons License
The article's content ©Academicus™ Effectiveness and legitimacy of Amicus Curiae submission before WTO judiciary organs. by Prof.As.Dr. Rezana Konomi , Dr. (PhD) Dorina Gjipali , MSc. Ntastin Perola is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.

Presented: April 2023
Included for Publishing: June 2023
Published: July 2023, Volume 14, Issue 28

Academicus International Scientific Journal is an Open Access Journal. This means that all content is freely available without charge to the user or his/her institution. Users are allowed to read, download, print, search, or link to the full texts of the articles in this journal without asking prior permission from the publisher or the author. This is in accordance with the BOAI definition of open access. Users are obliged to cite the source (Academicus International Scientific Journal) and the author, according to the international citation standards.
To learn more about the OA Policy followed by Academicus ISJ, read Journal Regulations 



Academicus
International Scientific Journal

pISSN 2079-3715
eISSN 2309-1088

Address:
Sheshi i Flamurit, Rruga Muze
Al-9401 Vlorë, Albania
Tel: +355 68 60 60 555
info@academicus.edu.al
https://academicus.edu.al